The case for discretion, the case for disclosure, and the middle path

Nearly half of women managers and executives, 45 percent, keep their menopause symptoms out of sight at work, and 34 percent have thought about quitting because of them, according to WebMD Health Services. Those figures describe one kind of woman: someone juggling a real medical experience and a professional reputation at once, with no guidebook for either. Choosing whether to mention it isn't a verdict on your character. It's a tactical call, and the best move depends on where you stand. The ten statements below will help you figure out your spot.

The questionnaire

Reply yes or no to each one, then tally the yeses.

Q1. A close colleague would notice how my symptoms have altered the way I carry myself at work.

Q2. Over the past quarter, something that mattered to me has been dropped, shortened or postponed on account of a symptom I was experiencing.

Q3. My manager has a track record of keeping personal details private.

Q4. At least one senior woman where I work has talked openly about menopause, caregiving or her health without any visible penalty.

Q5. Where I work, there is a documented policy on menopause, health or flexible scheduling that I would be able to point to.

Q6. Looking ahead, nothing in the next half year, whether a review, a promotion or a reorganization, has me on its calendar.

Q7. I can name a specific accommodation, such as a cooler office, a flexible start or a camera-off option, rather than just wishing for general understanding.

Q8. I trust that the person I'd confide in won't repeat it in a room I'm not part of.

Q9. Concealing these symptoms takes more out of me than a single, straightforward explanation would.

Question 10. I could lay out my situation in two sentences without apologizing.

Questions 1, 2, 7, 9 and 10 show how heavily the secrecy is weighing on you. Questions 3, 4, 5, 6 and 8 show how secure you would feel if you stopped hiding things. A sound decision requires looking at both columns.

Score

Zero to three: Keeping things private is working well for you. Hiding is cheap for you, or the ground isn't safe yet, or both. Choosing to keep a health matter to yourself while you wait to see how things develop is a perfectly reasonable decision in Sacramento or anywhere else.

Four to six: You sit somewhere in between. Concealment is beginning to cost you, and you have at least one trustworthy person to turn to. This is where most senior women actually find themselves, and it's the band with the most room to maneuver.

Seven to ten: Being open about it will probably cost you less in the long run. You're spending more to hide than you would to explain, and you have the conditions to do it well.

What to do next

Zero to three: Request the support you need while keeping the medical reason to yourself. "I do my best work in a cooler room and with a nine-thirty start on Tuesdays" requires no medical backstory, and most managers will agree without asking for one.

Four to six: Pick one trusted colleague, tell them on purpose, and include a specific ask. "Some menopause symptoms have been affecting me lately. They're under control, and one thing that would really help is camera-off for early calls." Two sentences, one ask, no apology, and the request gives them a concrete way to act on what you shared.

Seven to ten: Mention it as you would any logistical update, then return to the work at hand. The tone you set is the one others will mirror. Should your employer lack any formal policy, you could be the one who prompts the company to draft one.

Your result Share your band with your chapter group, and find out how many women two seats down are in the same place.