A scorecard for women who stopped checking years ago

The conventional wisdom still works, within limits. If you love your job, pay becomes a secondary concern. A supportive manager, meaningful work and colleagues you trust count for more than a few extra percentage points, and anyone who chases every dollar tends to end up unhappy. Many women who jumped ship for a 15% bump now find themselves miserable at a higher salary.

My argument runs the other way: loving your job is precisely when you are most likely to be underpaid, because the people setting your pay can see that you are not going anywhere.

1. Loyalty is priced in

Your paycheck reflects negotiation and timing far more than merit. It's determined by what it would cost to replace you, reduced by how likely you are to walk out. A 2025 McKinsey and LeanIn study showed only 54% of firms rank women's advancement as a top priority, and the remaining companies have made no move to fix that gap. Three signs to watch for: you haven't had a single conversation with an outside recruiter in three years. Each pay bump you've landed has matched the same flat rate applied across the board. You've never been counter-offered, because you've never given anyone a reason to.

2. The work grew and the number did not

The No Club, a book, points to research showing that women at one Southern California professional-services firm logged roughly 200 extra hours annually on work that earns no promotion, and they were requested about half again as often as men to shoulder it. When you enjoy your job, agreeing to take on more feels effortless. Three signs: your scope has expanded without a title change. You're training people you suspect earn more than you. Planning, note-taking and offsite logistics keep landing on your desk, and no one has ever tallied them.

3. The market moved while you were busy

Posted salary ranges are now mandatory in a growing number of states, so pay data is visible to anyone who bothers to look, and you haven't looked. Watch for three warning signals: a colleague hired at your level is earning more than you do. A recruiter in the East Bay quoted a salary range that left you stunned. You don't know the salary band for your own role, let alone where you fall within it.

Where the time-tested guidance still holds in California, from Sacramento to the Inland Empire

Don't swap a job you love for an extra 5%. That guidance only becomes a problem when you use it as a reason to stop reviewing your pay. You can cherish your work in Los Angeles and still understand its true market value. The women who get paid fairly in jobs they enjoy are the ones who kept track of their number while they stayed put.

Recommended next step

Measure your situation against the nine signs listed above. If you scored three or below, you're likely in good shape, so a yearly review will do. Four to six, and your pay is drifting; spend thirty minutes this week on a market check, pulling three posted ranges for your title in your metro area and noting the midpoint. Seven or more, and you are effectively subsidizing your employer, and affection for the job isn't a line item on your paycheck.

Then, in a regular one-on-one and without drama, say one sentence to your manager: "I'd like to understand where I sit in the salary range for my level, and what it would take to reach the midpoint." You aren't threatening to leave. You're asking a question about the numbers, and a manager who sidesteps it has already answered it.

Tally how many of the nine signs applied to you.

Sources: