Seven pieces of "wisdom" senior women wish they had ignored

Call her Dana. She is a blend of several people, so she isn't any one real member or client. She's 46, a senior vice president, and she's having lunch with a 31-year-old manager from her team who has just asked the question Carla once asked someone else: "What's the one piece of advice you'd give me?"

Carla is torn over a choice. Every bit of advice she received at 31 came from a senior person who meant well and was mistaken, and she took all of it to heart. Now she's trying to work out which one did the most harm, so she can flag that one first. Seven items make up the full tally on her list. Three still make her angry.

Route A. Stay low-profile and trust that your results will be recognized on their own

The downside: recognition rarely arrives without someone speaking up for the work. Someone else is always speaking up, and for Carla that someone was her manager, who claimed her output as his own across four full years. During those four years she earned exactly one promotion. He was promoted twice. The 2025 McKinsey and LeanIn report found that 31% of entry-level women have a sponsor, compared with 45% of men. Staying quiet is how many women land among the other 69% who are passed over.

Route B. Hold off on applying unless you satisfy each and every qualification listed.

What it costs: between 33 and 40, she passed on six openings she could have pursued. Tara Mohr's survey for Harvard Business Review found that women often skip jobs they feel underqualified for largely because they treat the listed requirements as hard rules, not because they lack confidence. Carla treated them as rules. The men who secured those six roles saw them as loose goals to chase.

Route C. Be grateful for the opportunity

The cost: she was grateful for every offer, which meant she accepted every first number put in front of her. A 2023 study from Berkeley Haas reported that 54% of women negotiated their most recent offer, compared with 44% of men, and women still earned less. Gratitude is a feeling, not a pay strategy, and the people who urged her to feel it weren't the ones signing her paycheck.

Counsel from veteran executives

Whenever women in leadership swap stories, the remaining four inevitably surface. "Wait your turn," which assumes there's a line and that someone is managing it. "Try not to aim so high," a phrase no man past 40 has ever been handed during a performance review. "Just be yourself," which means little without its missing half: "and find out what that costs in this place." And the one senior women most often rank as the worst: "If you're good, they'll notice." They will notice. Spotting an issue is one thing and doing something about it is another, and it's in that gap that a whole decade can slip away.

The executives also offer a gentler view. Nobody who handed her this guidance intended any harm. Those giving it had reached their own positions by another path and simply took for granted that the path was still available. The advice isn't a lie. It's an old map.

Verdict

Much depends on the career stage you were in when you made the choice. If you were already outspoken, "head down" won't have stuck. If you were already cautious, "every requirement" will have cost you the most, because you followed it to the letter. Carla's advice to any manager in Orange County or San Diego is the guidance she wished someone had given her: "Don't expect anyone to track your progress on your behalf, and keep score yourself."

Vote

Of these, which one did the most damage to you: A, B or C? Mail your letter to your chapter and we will share the findings in next month's issue. If the worst advice you were given isn't among these, pass that along as well. We capped the list at seven purely because that is all that would fit on the page.