The line items most people never add up, from equity to parental leave
Most people fixate on the headline salary, yet that single number tells you the least about what you will actually take home. Deloitte's 2025 survey of 7,500 women found that only 5% plan to remain with their employer for more than five years, so you will likely be weighing offers again sooner than you expect. It pays to learn how to total them up properly, starting now.
Picture the bigger offer landing $20,000 higher than the smaller one on base salary alone. Here is some illustrative arithmetic: a bonus target of 20% rather than 10% on a $200,000 salary is worth $20,000 a year on its own, and a retirement match of 6% instead of 3% adds another $6,000. The lower figure can come out ahead before you ever reach the second page of the letter.
The tally
Rank the lower offer higher. Go through each line and mark it yes or no, then total up your yeses.
First. Here the target bonus makes up a bigger slice of pay, and in each of the last two years the company reached or beat that goal.
Second. On the retirement match, one offer gives more, vests sooner, or does both.
Third. Equity is on the table, and you have a clear picture of the vesting timeline, the strike price or most recent valuation, and what happens to unvested shares if your employment ends.
Fourth. Parental or caregiving leave is longer and paid in full, and people in roles like yours actually use it.
Fifth. The title and who you report to are one rung higher than what the other offer gives you.
Sixth. The remote or hybrid arrangement appears in the offer letter itself, not just as a promise made in a hallway.
Seventh. Health coverage costs you less each month once you factor in premiums, deductibles and what it covers for your family.
Eighth. Vacation and paid time off are richer, and your interviewers really take their own days off.
Ninth. The salary band has headroom above you, so your next two raises are not capped by the top of the range.
Tenth. A signing bonus or retention award compensates you for what you walk away from when you switch employers, such as forfeited bonuses or unvested shares.
Reading your score
0 to 3: Take the higher figure. The smaller offer is, in fact, the smaller one. Accept the base salary, then push for better terms elsewhere, because the difference you just calculated gives you your case.
4 to 6: Closer than it looks. The $20,000 is likely real, but so is much of what the smaller offer holds. Assign a dollar value to every yes and compare the two totals next to each other. In plenty of cases the gap is under $5,000 in the first year and flips in favor of the other offer by year three.
7 to 10: The lower offer is actually the better deal. You are looking at a better-built package behind a lower headline. Base salary is the simplest number to negotiate, so start there.
Your following step
If you scored 0 to 3, go back to the smaller offer and say: "I'd like to accept, and I need the base to come up to X for the move to work." You have nothing to lose but a number.
If you scored 4 to 6, build a two-column sheet with every line priced, then ask each employer one question: "Is there flexibility on the line where you're behind?" Whoever answers with a number is showing you how much they want you.
With a 7 to 10 score, take the more valuable package and request that part of the base gap be paid now in cash, with the rest settled at a scheduled review. "Could we close half of that gap at signing and look at the remainder again at six months?"
Which offer scored higher on your card, and did it catch you off guard? Tell us.