Four things to negotiate before you sign, including the one HR hopes you won't notice

Think of a severance offer as the first offer on the table in a negotiation rather than a closing statement. The company is paying for your signature on a release of claims, and it has set that price at the smallest figure it believes you will take. According to a 2026 AARP survey, 64% of workers over 50 say they have faced age discrimination at work, a fact that may explain why companies push hardest for the release to be signed quickly and resist scrutiny of it.

Scrutinizing it is your right. Federal law grants workers aged 40 and older a review period before they are required to sign. Take all of it, and work through the check below before you answer anyone.

The tally

Look at the offer in your inbox and answer each item with a yes or a no.

1. Your payout exceeds what the company normally calculates, or you have requested a copy of that standard formula and received it.

2. Health coverage is paid by the company for a stated number of months, not merely offered to you as a chance to buy it yourself.

3. The letter clearly states whether your current-year bonus will be paid entirely or pro-rated.

4. Equity that has not yet vested, or retention bonuses scheduled to vest within the coming months, are either accelerated or cashed out.

5. The separation date specified in the letter works for your schedule, not just for the company's headcount planning.

6. The stated reason for leaving is phrased in a way that will not hurt your chances in your next role, for example, "position eliminated."

7. A non-disparagement provision exists, and the company is bound by it just as you are.

8. The non-compete or non-solicitation terms are limited enough to let you pursue the type of position you are most likely to secure next.

9. The package provides outplacement support, a letter of recommendation, or a pre-approved script for references.

10. You have had the release of claims reviewed by an attorney, or you intend to do so before signing.

Reading your score

A score of 0 to 3 means the offer is essentially a standard template. None of its terms, including the dollar amount, were tailored to your situation. That is not an insult. This is a starting point for negotiation, and it is meant to be countered.

4 to 7: Part of the package was already negotiated, perhaps by the last person who left. The gaps that remain are specific, which makes them easy to name and harder to refuse.

A score of 8 to 10 indicates a strong package. Your task is to protect it by confirming every line appears in the signed version, and by spending your review window reading the release rather than celebrating.

What to do next

If you scored 0 to 3, reply with four asks in one email: more weeks of pay, company-paid health coverage for a set number of months, the prorated bonus, and a mutual non-disparagement clause. "Thank you for sending this. Before I sign, I'd like to discuss four items." Your employer has budgeted for this conversation and expected it.

With a score of 4 to 7, pick the two items you marked no that matter most to you and ask for them specifically. A precise ask in Sacramento or Bakersfield usually gets a faster reply than a broad grievance.

With a score of 8 to 10, get an attorney to examine the release and any restrictive covenants before you sign. The provision HR hopes you won't notice is usually the non-compete, since a broad one costs the company nothing and can cost you your next offer. California workers can find free and low-cost help through the California Small Business Development Center network and local Women's Business Centers if they are weighing a move into self-employment.

Pass your score along, without identifying yourself, to the women who are likely to face this situation next. Many of them mistakenly believe the initial figure is the final one.

Sources: