Why fixing the wrong one wastes a year, and six questions that tell them apart

Picture her as Marisol, a composite rather than any real member or client. She is 47, a vice president of marketing, and for eleven months she has been rewriting her résumé on Sunday nights without sending a single copy. Ask her why and she says she is simply worn out by marketing. Her husband, who has listened to stories about her new manager every evening since February, suspects something else entirely.

That manager first appeared in February. He skips her one-on-ones, passes her work up to the CEO with someone else's name on it, and in meetings asks whether she has "pressure-tested" things she already launched. Prior to that month, she had taken real pleasure in her work. For some reason she no longer remembers that she once felt this way.

Where the risk lies

If the trouble is the role and she handles it as though it were the manager, she will sit out his tenure and still feel miserable once he is gone. If the trouble is the manager and she handles it as though it were the role, she will walk away from a company she once loved, enter an industry she barely knows, and carry him along in her head anyway. Either misreading tends to waste roughly a year.

The turning point

The useful question is not "do I like my boss?" Hardly anyone enjoys a poor manager, and many people resent a decent one. A better question is what shifts once the manager is taken out of the frame. Marisol tests it on her commute. She pictures him promoted to some distant office and a capable, unremarkable successor sitting in his seat. The projects are identical, and so is the team. She catches herself smiling. That reaction matters. It is the answer.

Why Marisol's story applies more widely

A 2025 TalentLMS survey of 1,000 workers found that 54 percent describe "quiet cracking," a gradual erosion of motivation that never looks like a resignation until the day it does. A difficult manager is one of the quickest routes into that state, and the harm is easy to mislabel as "I'm finished with this career." The career is often sound. What stands in the way is the person sitting above her.

Six prompts to consider

1. Imagine your manager left the company tomorrow and everything else stayed put; would you remain? A fast yes points to the boss.

2. Before this supervisor came along, were you satisfied with the position? If so, the boss is the likely cause.

3. Have three consecutive managers left you unable to work well with them? Then examine the role more closely, or the type of work you are doing.

4. Does your dread show up before meetings with one particular person, or before Mondays in general? Dread tied to a person points to a person. Dread that hangs over everything points to the role.

5. On difficult days, does your work still pull at your interest? When it does, the role itself is most likely not what's wrong.

6. When you imagine your next position, is it the same work under a different leader, or completely different work? Pay attention to what that picture shows you.

Deciding how to act on what you've learned

If four or more answers point to the boss, the remedy is usually a direct conversation or an internal transfer, not a complete career pivot. Begin inside the organization: "I'd like to understand how you prefer to work with me. Here is what I need from you so I can do my best work." Then agree on a checkpoint, perhaps ninety days out. If nothing improves, take specifics, not feelings, to his manager or to HR. If the answers point to the job, stop placing the blame on the February arrival. He is not worth a lost year.

On Sunday night, Marisol's résumé remains unfinished. This week, for the first time, she knows who it is meant for.